Collectible card case clash leads filings | Full Court Press

Marathon County civil court cases for March 2026

Once per month, The Wausonian digs through the civil court filings in Marathon County to find the most interesting cases. It’s one of The Wausonian’s signature features — and one you won’t find anywhere else.

Almost made it in time! Next week I should be back to fully caught up on this feature.

Joseph Tofferi ran a collectibles social media channel with his son and he wanted to buy some top-notch baseball cards for it.

He found five rare cards to buy online, and arranged with Steven Lyons to buy them. The costs for the five cards, which included a 1984 Michael Jordan card among other football, baseball and basketball cards, was $21,100.

But, Tofferi alleges in the lawsuit, that’s where the trouble began.